Why Do We Keep Hoping There's One Thing That Will Fix Sales and Marketing?

How to work out where your time and money are worth going, when you've been promised results before.

I had two conversations this week with founders running very different businesses but both with the same wish.

If someone could just point me at the one thing that consistently gets us new customers, I'd put the money behind it tomorrow.

Both have tried the basics across marketing, paid for some help, and watched it not quite deliver what they were told it would. There was a tiredness to it that I recognised straight away. Less I don't want to do this, more I'd really love it to be simple, for once.

As a Growth Partner, it comes up in almost every sales conversation I have. And the closest thing to a silver bullet I've found is a lot less exciting than anyone hopes: a few small, steady things, done for long enough that you can see what’s working, so investing more feels less like a leap of faith.

The tension underneath

In digital marketing and outbound sales especially, plenty of agencies and freelancers will promise a result, a number of leads at a certain price. The trouble is that result depends on a platform, a market and a moment, and none of those belong to the person making the promise.

Both founders I spoke with had been promised things that never came, more than once, and you could hear it in how carefully they talked about trying anything new.

Wanting the one thing that works can sound like a question about channels, but underneath, I think it’s about trust. When you’ve put money into something and watched it disappear, wanting one clear answer is a very human way of protecting yourself from doing it again.

The assumptions most founders make

That wish for one clear answer usually turns into a search for the person who has it. Somewhere out there, surely, is someone who has cracked it, and once you find them you can hand it over and get back to the work you love.

Maybe this time it’ll be the right one.

It’s a completely reasonable thought, especially if sales isn’t where you feel at home. From the outside, sales can even look like the simple part, because someone either bought or they didn’t. So when the sales don’t come, it’s easy to think you simply backed the wrong person, and go looking for someone better.

What was actually going on

Sometimes the issue isn't that nothing works... it's that no single thing gets the credit.

I recently decided to switch to loose leaf tea, and the first place I went was Bird & Blend. I’d never bought from them and didn’t look anywhere else. But I’d noticed them for years, they’re a Sussex business I feel aligned with, and somewhere along the way I’d come to trust them. Ask me which advert, post or sponsored event did it and I honestly couldn’t tell you. It was all of them, over time.

From my experience in sales, that’s how most buying works, because what people are really buying is trust. It’s a few calm, low-pressure moments where someone hears from you, finds you helpful, and remembers your name when the time is right for them. So when you test one channel for a few weeks and judge it on immediate sales, it can look like it failed even when it was quietly doing its part.

The moment things shifted

In both conversations, I asked a version of the same question: what are you really looking for? Both answered honestly, then caught themselves in the same breath. One described someone pointing at a channel and saying do this, and you’ll get customers at this price, half wondering if that was a fantasy. The other described their dream scenario, the right person coming in to take on the commercial side, then said they just didn’t know how you’d magic that up.

What they were really asking for, it seemed to me, was confidence: enough certainty to feel safe putting more in, after being let down before.

The bit founders don’t always see

From my own experience, that kind of confidence rarely arrives all at once. I think of it a bit like a garden. It looks simple: you plant something, water it, and wait. But the soil, the weather and the season all play their part, so nobody blames a single packet of seeds, or the gardener, when something doesn’t come up. A good gardener wouldn’t promise exactly what will flower, or when. They plant, watch and adjust, knowing it’s often a while before anything shows.

Sales and marketing work the same way. Who you’re talking to, what you say, where they find you and what happens next all play a part, and most people need to hear from you several times before they’re ready to buy. The world keeps shifting too, so what worked last year might not this year. That’s why a silver bullet can’t really exist: even if you found one today, it wouldn’t stay one for long. What lasts is planting a few things on purpose, noticing what’s starting to take, and putting more behind those, season after season.

Where I learned this (the long way)

I should know, because I used to be the founder hoping someone could just hand me the one approach that worked. At the Good Business Club, I got by because I could hustle and talk. But sales took so much of my energy, mostly because I was pushing too hard, and when it didn’t land, I just pushed harder.

It started to change when Ben, who later became my co-founder at Second Voice, introduced me to consultative selling. As he’d put it, you wouldn’t walk up to someone on a first date and ask them to marry you. Taking the pressure off and getting curious fitted me so much better, and it turns out it was better for selling too!

Running a sales agency showed me how many moving parts there are, and how much comes down to trust and turning up steadily. I know what it’s like to not know. And I know what a difference knowing makes.

A more grounded way to look at it

If this is resonating with your view of marketing and sales, here’s something to consider.

Instead of asking: What’s the one thing that works?

It’s often more useful to ask: How could we find out what works for us, right now?

That might look like:

  • Looking at what you’ve already tried, and what it shows about who responded, where, and to what.

  • Testing a few things side by side, with a set time and something specific to look for.

  • Showing up where your customers already are, with something helpful, and talking to them.

  • Blocking a couple of hours every week, so it keeps moving when you’re busy.

  • Reviewing it every few months, because what worked last season might not now.

Because here’s the truth

There's no silver bullet, because what works keeps changing. What you can back is a steady way of finding out: a few tests, given time and reviewed as you go. That’s what turns a leap of faith into a decision you feel confident making.

One thing to take away

If you've been let down before, and part of you is still hoping for the one thing that will work, I wouldn't jump straight to looking for who can promise it.

I'd ask:

What would I need to see from a small test to feel confident putting more behind it?

Next
Next

Why Do the Conversations That Matter Most Take the Longest to Have?